Performance Comparison of Transversely and Longitudinally Fractured Horizontal Wells Over Varied Reservoir Permeability
- Fen Yang (Missouri University of Science and Technology) | Larry K. Britt (NSI Fracturing) | Shari Dunn-Norman (Missouri University of Science and Technology)
- Document ID
- Society of Petroleum Engineers
- SPE Journal
- Publication Date
- October 2016
- Document Type
- Journal Paper
- 1,537 - 1,553
- 2016.Society of Petroleum Engineers
- Fractured horizontal well performance comparison, Transverse and longitudinal fractures, Critical reservoir permeability, Gas and Oil Reservoir simulation, Economic analysis and sensitivity study
- 3 in the last 30 days
- 417 since 2007
- Show more detail
- View rights & permissions
|SPE Member Price:||USD 10.00|
|SPE Non-Member Price:||USD 30.00|
Since the late 1980s when Maersk published their work on multiple fracturing of horizontal wells in the Dan field, the use of transverse multiple-fractured horizontal wells has become the completion of choice and the “industry standard” for unconventional and tight-oil and tight-gas reservoirs. Today, approximately 60% of all wells drilled in the United States are drilled horizontally, and nearly all are multiple-fractured. However, little work has been performed to address and understand the relationship between the principal stresses and the lateral direction. This paper has as its goal to fundamentally address the questions: In which direction should I drill my lateral? Do I drill it in the direction of the maximum horizontal stress (longitudinal), or do I drill it in the direction of the minimum horizontal stress (transverse)?
This work focuses on how the horizontal well’s lateral direction (longitudinal or transverse fracture orientation) influences productivity, reserves, and economics of horizontal wells. Optimization studies, with a single-phase fully 3D numerical simulator including convergent non-Darcy flow, were used to highlight the importance of lateral direction as a function of reservoir permeability. The simulations, conducted for both oil and gas formations over a wide range of reservoir permeability (50 nd–5 md), compare and contrast the performance of transversely multiple-fractured horizontal wells with longitudinally fractured horizontal wells in terms of rate, recovery, and economics. This work also includes a series of field case studies to illustrate actual field comparisons of longitudinal vs. transverse horizontal well performance in both oil and gas reservoirs, and to tie these field examples to the numerical-simulation study. Further, the effects of lateral length, fracture half-length, and fracture conductivity were investigated to see how these parameters affect the decision of lateral direction in both oil and gas reservoirs. In addition, this study seeks to address how completion style (openhole or cased-hole completion) affects the selection of lateral direction.
The results show the existence of a critical reservoir permeability, above which longitudinal fractured horizontal wells outperform transverse fractured horizontal wells. With openhole completions, the critical permeability is 0.04 md for gas reservoirs and 0.4 md for oil reservoirs. With cased-hole completions, longitudinal horizontal wells are preferred at a reservoir permeability above 1.5 md in gas reservoirs, and transverse horizontal wells are preferable over the entire permeability range of this study (50 nd–5 md) in oil reservoirs. These are new findings. Previous work generally suggested that longitudinal horizontal wells are a better option for gas reservoirs with permeability over 0.5 md, and for oil reservoirs with permeability over 10 md.
This work extends prior study to include unconventional reservoir permeabilities. It provides critical permeability values for both gas and oil reservoirs, which are validated by the good compliance between actual field-case history and simulation results. This work also demonstrates a larger impact of completion method over fracture design. These findings could guide field operations and serve as a reference for similar studies.
|File Size||1 MB||Number of Pages||17|
Bennet, C. O. 1982. Analysis of Fractured Wells. PhD dissertation, University of Tulsa, Tulsa, Oklahoma.
Bowker, K. A. 2007. Barnett Shale Gas Production, Fort Worth Basin: Issues and Discussion. AAPG Bull. 91 (4): 523–533. http://dx.doi.org/10.1306/06190606018.
Britt, L. K. and Smith, M. B. 2009. Horizontal Well Completion and Stimulation Optimization and Risk Mitigation Strategies. Presented at the Eastern Regional Meeting, Charleston, West Virginia. USA, 23–25 September. SPE-125526-MS. http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/125526-MS.
Britt, L. K. 2014. HAMP Hugoton Review of Consortium Operator’s Horizontal Wells. MH.
Craft, J. R. 2011. A Ground-Breaking Approach—Emerging Unconventional Oil and Liquids-Rich Gas Targets. Presented at the DUG Conference, 19 April 2011.
Economides, M. J. and Martin, T. 2007. Modern Fracturing—Enhancing Natural Gas Production. Energy Tribune.
Economides, M. J., Marongiu-Porcu, M., Yang, M. et al. 2010. Fracturing Horizontal Transverse, Horizontal Longitudinal and Vertical. Presented at the Canadian Unconventional Resources and International Petroleum Conference, Calgary, 19–21 October. SPE-137328-MS. http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/137328-MS.
Gale, J., Redd, F. W., Robert, M. et al. 2007. Natural Fractures in the Barnett Shale and Their Importance for Hydraulic Fracture Treatments. GeoScienceWorld, webpage. 2014. Stress Map. Also in AAPG Bull. April 2007. Vol. 91, No. 4, Page 605.
Gong, X., Tian, Y., Mcvay D. A. et al. 2013. Assessment of Eagle Ford Shale Oil and Gas Resources. Presented at the SPE Unconventional Resources Conference–Canada, Calgary, 5–7 November. SPE-167241-MS. http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/167241-MS.
Gulf Oil & Gas. 2014. Eagle Ford Introduction. (http://www.gulfoilandgas.com/webpro1/unconventional/oil-shale-projects.asp) (accessed 9 September 2014).
InvestingDaily. 2014. Bakken Sahle Map: An Investor’s Introduction to the Formation by ID Analysts on March 17, 2012. Source: US Energy Information Administration. http://www.investingdaily.com/15159/bakkenshale-map-an-investors-introduction-to-the-formation/ (accessed 9 September 2014).
Lafollette, R. F. and Holcomb, W. D. 2011. Practical Data Mining: Lessons Learned From the Barnett Shale of North Texas, p. 9 of 13. Presented at the SPE Hydraulic Fracturing Technology Conference and Exhibition, The Woodlands, Texas, USA, 24–26 January. SPE-140524-MS. http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/140524-MS.
Liu, T., Marongiu-Porcu, M., Ehlig-Economides, C. et al. 2012. A Study of Transversely vs. Longitudinally Fractured Horizontal Wells in a Moderate-Permeability Gas Reservoir. Presented at the SPE Kuwait International Petroleum Conference and Exhibition, Kuwait City, Kuwait, 10–12 December. SPE-163317-MS. http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/163317-MS.
Menchaca, M. 2014. Stressing Out on the Eagle Ford: Shale Play Geology. Drillinginfo. Source: DI Analytics. http://info.drillinginfo.com/stresseagle-ford-shale-play-geology/ (accessed 9 September 2014).
National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL). 2014. Geomechanical Study of Bakken Formation for Improved Oil Recovery (last reviewed 24 June 2014), DE-08NT005643, Fig. 2 Orientation of Maximum Horizontal In-situ Stress in the Bakken Formation, Williston Basin, North Dakota. http://www.netl.doe.gov/research/oil-and-gas/project-summaries/enhanced-oil-recovery/05643_geomech_bakken (accessed 10 September 2014).
NDIC. 2014. North Dakota Industrial Commission. North Dakota Industrial Commission, Department of Mineral Resources, Oil and Gas Division. www.dmr.nd.gov (accessed 5 June 2014).
Oil & Gas Journal. 2014. Barnett Shale Map. (http://www.ogj.com/unconventional-resources/barnett-play-map.html).
Prats, M. 1961. Effect of Vertical Fractures on Reservoir Behavior-Incompressible Fluid Case. SPE J. 1 (2): 105–118. SPE-1575-G. http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/1575-G.
Rahim, Z., Al-Anazi, H., Al-Kanaan, A. et al. 2012. Improved Gas Recovery-2 (Conclusion): Productivity Increase Using Hydraulic Fracturing-Expectation Vs. Reality. Oil & Gas J. (May).
Shale Experts. 2014. Permian Basin Overview. (http://www.shaleexperts.com/plays/permian-basin/Overview).
Shale Stuff. 2013. Sizing up the Permian Basin, 30 October 2013, (http://shalestuff.com/controversy-2/sizing-permian-basin/article09595).
Stevens, B. (2014, September 17). Technical: Fracking What Makes it Tick?— Demystifying the Why’s, Technology, and Science Behind Unconventional Oil and Shale Gas Extraction. Retrieved from BarryOnEnergy.
Texas File. 2014. Zavala_County. (http://www.texasfile.com/texas-deedrecords-directory/zavala-county-clerk/).
Thomas, M. W. 2013. Eagle Ford Shale Play. San Antonio Business Journal. (www.bizjounals.com).
Valkó, P. and Economides, M. J. 1996. Performance of Fractured Horizontal Wells in High-Permeability Reservoirs. Presented at the SPE International Symposium on Formation Damage Control in Lafayette, Louisiana, USA, 14–15 February. SPE-31149-MS. http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/31149-MS.
Wutherich, K., Xu, L., Walker, K. et al. 2013. Quantifying the Effect of Drilling Azimuth in Shale Gas Reservoirs. Presented at the SPE Eastern Regional Meeting, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA, 20–22 August. SPE-165672-MS. http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/165672-MS.
Zinn, C., Blood D. R., and Morath, P. 2011. Evaluating the Impact of Wellbore Azimuth in the Marcellus Shale. Presented at the SPE Eastern Regional Meeting, Columbus, Ohio, USA, 17–19 August. SPE-149468-MS. http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/149468-MS.
Zoback, M. L. and Zoback, M. 1980. States of Stress in Conterminous United States. J. Geophysical Research 85 (B11): 6113–6156.