Reserves Overbooking: The Problem We're Finally Going to Talk About
- Grant T. Olsen (Texas A&M University) | W. John Lee (Texas A&M University) | Thomas Blasingame (Texas A&M University)
- Document ID
- Society of Petroleum Engineers
- SPE Economics & Management
- Publication Date
- April 2011
- Document Type
- Journal Paper
- 68 - 78
- 2011. Society of Petroleum Engineers
- 5.7 Reserves Evaluation
- ethics, reserves, SEC filing
- 1 in the last 30 days
- 1,502 since 2007
- Show more detail
- View rights & permissions
|SPE Member Price:||USD 5.00|
|SPE Non-Member Price:||USD 35.00|
Oil and gas reserves estimates that honor disclosure requirements of the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) are critically important in the international oil and gas industry. Unfortunately, a number of exploration and production (E&P) companies have allegedly overstated and subsequently written down certain reserves volumes in recent years. In some cases, the consequences have been quite adverse. We document some of these cases of reserves overstatements and summarize the consequences. Reserves write downs are of obvious interest to numerous groups involved in the reserves estimation process and outcome, including estimators, managers, investors, creditors, and regulators. The magnitude and nature of recent overstatement cases, relative unfamiliarity with the SEC's inner workings, and the SEC's new reserves-reporting requirements increase the need to examine critically reserves disclosures and reserves overstatements.
|File Size||288 KB||Number of Pages||11|
42 USC Chapter 77--Energy Conservation. 2008. Washington, DC: Officeof the Law Revision Counsel, US House of Representatives.
Barry, R. 1993. The Management of International Oil Operations.Tulsa, Oklahoma: PennWell Books.
Cronquist, C. 2001. Estimation and Classification of Reserves of CrudeOil, Natural Gas, and Condensate. Richardson, Texas: SPE.
Darbonne, N. 2009a. Year-End Reserve Rules May Affect M&A Deals as Soonas Now. Oil and Gas Investor (March): 32-36.
Darbonne, N. 2009b. 2010 SEC Reserve-Reporting Rules May Affect M&ADeal-Making As Soon As Now. Oil and Gas Investor Blog, 27 January 2009,http://blogs.oilandgasinvestor.com/blog/2009/01/27/2010-sec-reserve-reporting-rules-may-affect-ma-deal-making-as-soon-as-now/.
Davis, M. 2004. Reserves Haunt El Paso, Shell. The Street, 20February 2004, http://www.thestreet.com/story/10144727/reserves-haunt-el-paso-shell.html(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Dharan, B.G. 2004a. Prepared testimony for the US House Committee onFinancial Services, 108th Congress, Second Session. Improving the Relevance andReliability of Oil and Gas Reserves Disclosures, 31-50. Hearing, 21 July 2004(Serial No. 108-105), Shell Games: Corporate Governance and Accounting for Oiland Gas Reserves, http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov/cgi-bin/getdoc.cgi?dbname=108_house_hearings&docid=f:96549.pdf(downloaded 14 January 2010).
Dharan, B.G. 2004b. Spoken testimony before the US House Committee onFinancial Services, 108th Congress, Second Session. Improving the Relevance andReliability of Oil and Gas Reserves Disclosures, 13-15. Hearing, 21 July 2004(Serial No. 108-105), Shell Games: Corporate Governance and Accounting for Oiland Gas Reserves, http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov/cgi-bin/getdoc.cgi?dbname=108_house_hearings&docid=f:96549.pdf.(downloaded 14 January 2010).
Egoy, M. 2008. Shell settles oil reserves-related US lawsuit UPDATE.Forbes.com, 06 March 2008, http://www.forbes.com/feeds/afx/2008/03/06/afx4740525.html(downloaded 22 June 2010).
El Paso Corp. to Review Plan for Production Business Conference Call--Final.2004b. Fair Disclosure Wire (29 June 2004).
El Paso Firemen and Policemen's Pension Fund v. Stone Energy Corporation.2006. Case 6:05-cv-02088-TLM-MEM, Doc. 61 (W.D. La. 14 June 2006), http://securities.stanford.edu/1035/SGY05_01/2006614_r01c_052088.pdf(downloaded 22 June 2010).
El Paso to Review Reserve Revisions Conference Call. 2004a. FairDisclosure Wire (17 February 2004).
Etherington, J.R. 2009. Managing Your Business Using Intergrated PRMS andSEC Standards. Paper SPE 124398 presented at the SPE Annual TechnicalConference and Exhibition, New Orleans, 4-7 October. doi: 10.2118/124938-MS.
FASB Accounting Standards Codification™ --Notice to Constituents (v 2.0).2009. Norwalk, Connecticut: FASB. http://asc.fasb.org/imageRoot/63/6537863.pdf(downloaded 14 January 2010).
FASB Accounting Standards Update. Extractive Industries--Oil and Gas (Topic932): Oil and Gas Reserve Estimation and Disclosures, No. 2010-03. 2010a.Norwalk, Connecticut: Financial Accounting Series, FASB. http://www.fasb.org/cs/ContentServer?c=Document_C&pagename=FASB%2FDocument_C%2FDocumentPage&cid=1176156601659(downloaded 1 March 2010).
Feiten, J.B. 2007. Form 10-KSB for Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2005 andForm 10-Q for Fiscal Quarters Ended March 31, 2006, June 30, 2006, andSeptember 30, 2006. Comment Letter, American Oil & Gas, Inc, Houston,Texas.
Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB). 2010b. Facts About FASB, http://www.fasb.org/jsp/FASB/Page/SectionPage&cid=1176154526495(accessed 14 January 2010).
Gifis, S.H. 1996. Law Dictionary, fourth edition. Hauppauge, NewYork: Legal Guides, Barron's Educational Series.
Gold, R. 2008. El Paso Ex-Executives Settle Charges Over Reserves. The WallStreet Journal (12 July 2008): B6. http://royaldutchshellplc.com/2008/07/12/el-paso-ex-executives-settle-charges-over-reserves/(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Harrell, D.R. and Gardner, T.L. 2005. Significant Differences in ProvedReserves Estimates Using SPE/WPC Definitions Compared to United StatesSecurities and Exchange Commission Definitions. SPE Res Eval & Eng 8 (6): 520-527. SPE-84145-PA. doi: 10.2118/84145-PA.
Harrell, D.R., Hodgin, J.E., and Wagenhofer, T. 2004. Oil and Gas ReservesEstimates: Recurring Mistakes and Errors. Paper SPE 91069 presented at the SPEAnnual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Houston, 26-29 September. doi: 10.2118/91069-MS.
Hodgin, J. 2009. An Introduction to the US Securities and Exchange Oil andGas Regulations and the 2008 SEC "Modernization of Oil and Gas Reporting."Presentation given at the 2009 Ryder Scott Reserves Conference, Houston, 8May.
Hodgin, J.E. and Harrell, D.R. 2006. The Selection, Application, andMisapplication of Reservoir Analogs for the Estimation of Petroleum Reserves.Paper SPE 102505 presented at SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition,San Antonio, Texas, USA, 24-27 September. doi: 10.2118/102505-MS.
Kopytoff, V. 2004. SEC questions oil giants' reserves. San FranciscoChronicle, 10 April 2004, C-1; SFGate, http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2004/04/10/BUGT9632791.DTL(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Labaton, S. and Gerth, J. 2004. Justice Dept. Opens Inquiry Into Shell Oil.The New York Times, 17 March 2004, http://www.nytimes.com/2004/03/17/business/justice-dept-opens-inquiry-into-shell-oil.html?pagewanted=1(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Larsen, J., Buckberg, E., and Lev, B. 2008. SEC Settlements: A New EraPost-SOX. Research report, NERA Economic Consulting (10 November 2008), http://www.securitieslitigationtrends.com/Settlements_Report.pdf(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Larsen, J., Buckberg, E., and Lev, B. 2009. SEC Settlement Trends: 3Q09Update. Research report, NERA Economic Consulting (07 December 2009), http://www.nera.com/image/PUB_Settlements_Update_Q3_1209.pdf(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Lee, W.J. 2009. Modernization of the SEC Oil and Gas Reserves ReportingRequirements. SPE Econ & Mgmt 1 (1): 4-10.SPE-123793-PA. doi:10.2118/123793-PA.
Macalister, T. 2004. Chinese disposal will reap $1bn profit for BP. TheGuardian, 13 January 2004, http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2004/jan/13/china.oilandpetrol(downloaded 22 June 2010).
McArthur, J.B. 1996. The Class Action Tool in Oilfield Litigation. TheKansas Law Review 45 (November): 113.
McLane, M.A. and Rose, P.R. 2001. Reserve Overbooking--The Problem No OneWants to Talk About. Paper SPE 68580 presented at the SPE Hydrocarbon Economicsand Evaluation Symposium, Dallas, 2-3 April. doi: 10.2118/68580-MS.
Meyer, W.M. and Zorn, R.E. 2004. Issue Spotlight--Oil & Gas Reserves.Presentation, Simmons & Company International (25 February 2010), http://www.simmonsco-intl.com/(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Morehouse, D.F. 1997. The Intricate Puzzle of Oil and Gas "Reserves Growth."Natural Gas Monthly (July), http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/oil_gas/petroleum/feature_articles/1997/intricate_puzzle_reserves_growth/m07fa.pdf(downloaded 18 February 2010).
Mouawad, J. 2009. Shell Faces Even More Revamping. The New YorkTimes, 29 June 2009, B1.
Oxley, M.G. 2004. Spoken testimony before the US House Committee onFinancial Services, 108th Congress, Second Session. Opening Statement, 28-29.Hearing, 21 July 2004 (Serial No. 108-105), Shell Games: Corporate Governanceand Accounting for Oil and Gas Reserves, http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov/cgi-bin/getdoc.cgi?dbname=108_house_hearings&docid=f:96549.pdf(downloaded 14 January 2010).
Pennsylvania Employees Retirement System v. Royal Dutch/Shell. 2005. Civ.Action No. 04-374, (D. N.J. 19 September 2005), http://securities.stanford.edu/1029/RD04-01/2005919_r01c_0400374.pdf(downloaded 04 February 2010).
Perin, M. 2002. El Paso, Coastal merger produces proved reserves jugglingact. Houston Business Journal, 10 November 2002, http://Houston.bizjournals.com/houston/stories/2002/11/11/story2.html(accessed 7 February 2010).
Plancich, S. and Starykh, S. 2009. Recent Trends in Securities Class ActionLitigation: 2009 Mid-Year Update. Research report, NERA Economic Consulting(July 2009), http://www.nera.com/extImage/Recent_Trends_Report_07_09.pdf(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Plourd, K. 2008. Energy Firm Settles Overstated Reserves Case. CFO.com, 11July 2008, http://www.cfo.com/printable/article.cfm/11732458/c_11730641?f=options(downloaded 07 Februrary 2010).
REPSOL YPF SA. 2006. Estimated Reserves Revision. Presentation, Form 6-K,Commission File No. 001-10220, Securities and Exchange Commission, Washington,DC (26 January 2006).
Reservations about Reserves. 2004. Rigzone, 13 January 2004, http://www.rigzone.com/news/article.asp?a_id=10380(accessed 06 December 2009).
Reynolds v. Repsol YPF. 2006. Civ. Action No. 1:06-cv-00733-RCC. (S.D.N.Y. 1September 2006), http://securities.stanford.edu/1035/REP_01/200691_r01c_06733.pdf(downloaded 7 February 2010).
Robertson, D. 2006. SEC Drops Investigation of Watts. The Times, 31 August2006, http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/law/article623403.ece(accessed 05 February 2010).
Roesle, D. 2007. Reserves Estimation in Accounting and Reporting.Presentation given at the Oklahoma State University Oil & Gas AccountingConference, Stillwater, Oklahoma, USA, 16 November. http://www.ryderscott.com/OSUOil&GasEnergyConference.ppt(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Ryder Scott. 2003. Ryder Scott to present reserves topics at ATCE.Reservoir Solutions 6 (3): 4-5. http://www.ryderscott.com/download/903nsltr.pdf(downloaded 5 February 2010).
Schaumann, N.B. 2002. Securities Regulation. Chicago, Illinois:Gilbert Law Summaries, The BarBri Group.
Schroeder, S.C. 2008. Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2006.Comment Letter, Cabot Oil & Gas, Houston, Texas (1 May 2008).
SEC v. El Paso. 2008. Case No. 4:08-cv-02191, Doc. 1, (S.D. Tx, 11 July2008).
SEC v. Royal Dutch Petroleum Co., et al. 2004. Complaint H-04-3359 No. 18844(S.D. Tx 24 August 2004), http://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/comp18844.pdf(downloaded 4 February 2010).
Shell difficulties 'could spread'. 2004. BBC News, 19 March 2004, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/3551711.stm(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Shell settles fraud case for $150M. 2004. CNN/Money.com, http://money.cnn.com/2004/08/24/news/international/royaldutchshell_sec/(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Shell Transport and Trading Company PLC Conference Call--Final. 2004a.Fair Disclosure Wire (09 January 2004).
Shell Transport and Trading Company PLC Earnings Conference Call andPresentation--London--Final. 2004b. Fair Disclosure Wire (05 February2004).
Smith, A.L. and Sheehan C.W. 1997. PDP vs. PUD: Assessing the Risks ofProved Undeveloped Reserve (PUD) Revisions and Writedowns. Herold IndustryInsights (30 October1997).
Snow, N. 2006. Reserves Reporting Dilemma. Oil & Gas FinancialJournal (01 March 2006).
SPE. 2007. Standards Pertaining to the Estimating and Auditing of Oil andGas Reserves Information,http://www.spe.org/spe-site/spe/spe/industry/reserves/Reserves_Audit_Standards_2007.pdf(19 February 2007 revision).
SPE/WPC/AAPG/SPEE. 2007. Petroleum Resources Management System--2007, http://www.spe.org/spe-app/spe/industry/reserves/prms.htm.
Spear, N.A. and Lee, R.E.N. 1999. An empirical examination of thereliability of proved reserve quantity data. Petroleum Accounting andFinancial Management Journal 18 (2): 1-23.
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 69, Disclosures about Oiland Gas Producing Activities, an amendment of FASB Statements 19, 25, 33, and39. 1982. Norwalk, Connecticut: FASB. http://www.fasb.org/st/summary/stsum69.shtml(Downloaded 10 January 2010).
Stichting Shell Reserves Compensation Foundation. 2009. Amsterdam Court ofAppeals Declares Shell Settlement Binding. Press Release, The Hague, 29 May2009, http://www.shellsettlement.com/docs/20090529-press%20release%20amsterdam%20court%20of%20appeals%20declares%20shell%20settlement%20binding.pdf(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Stone Energy Corporation Securities Litigation. 2010. Summary NoticePublication. PRNewswire, 27 January 2010, http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/stone-energy-corporation-securities-litigation-82809552.html(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Stone Energy Corporation. 2005a. Provides Production and Hurricane Updateand Revisions to Reserves. Press Release, Lafayette, Louisiana, USA, 6 October2005, http://www.stoneenergy.com/pdf/press/2005/rsvupdate10-05.pdf(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Stone Energy Corporation. 2005b. Announces Restatement of HistoricalFinancial Statements and Provides Third Quarter 2005 Selected Financial Dataand Operational Update. Press Release, Lafayette, Louisiana, USA, 8 November2005, http://www.stoneenergy.com/pdf/press/2005/3QT05SelectedDataZ.pdf(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Stone Energy Corporation. 2005c. Announces EC Inquiry. Press Release,Lafayette, Louisiana, USA, 10 November 2005, http://www.stoneenergy.com/pdf/press/2005/SECInquiry11-05.pdf(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Stone Energy Corporation. 2005d. Announces Findings of Independent Review.Press Release, Lafayette, Louisiana, USA, 5 December 2005, http://www.stoneenergy.com/pdf/press/2005/ReviewFindings.pdf(downloaded 22 June 2010).
Stone Energy Corporation. 2007. 2007 Annual Report, http://www.stoneenergy.com/pdf/ar/Stone07AR.pdf(downloaded 7 February 2010).
Stone Energy Corporation. 2008. Putting the Pieces Together: 2008 AnnualReport, http://www.stoneenergy.com/pdf/ar/Stone08AR.pdf(downloaded 7 February 2010).
US SEC CF Accounting Staff. 2001. Frequently Requested Accounting andFinancial Reporting Interpretations and Guidance--Guidance AboutDisclosures--F. Issues in the Extractive Industries--3. Definition of ProvedReserves. US SEC Division of Corporation Finance, Washington, DC (31 March2001), http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/guidance/cfactfaq.htm#P279_57537(accessed 15 February 2010).
US SEC. 2004a. SEC Staff to Publicly Release Comment Letters and Responses.Press release 2004-89, US Securities and Exchange Commission, Washington, DC(24 June 2004), http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2004-89.htm(accessed 22 June 2010).
US SEC. 2004b. Royal Dutch Petroleum Company and the "Shell" Transport andTrading Company, P.L.C. Pay $120 Million to Settle SEC Fraud Case InvolvingMassive Overstatement of Proved Hydrocarbon Reserves. Press release 2004-116,US Securities and Exchange Commission, Washington, DC (24 August 2004), http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2004-116.htm(accessed 22 June 2010).
US SEC. 2008a. Modernization of the Oil and Gas Reporting Requirements.Conforming version (proposed rule), 17 CFR Parts 210, 229, and 249, [ReleaseNos. 33-8935; 34-58030; File No. S7-15-08], RIN 3235-AK00, US Securities andExchange Commission, Washington, DC (27 June 2008), http://www.sec.gov/rules/proposed/2008/33-8935.pdf.
US SEC. 2008b. Comments, Modernization of the Oil and Gas ReportingRequirements. Conforming version (proposed rule), 17 CFR Parts 210, 229 and249, [Release Nos. 33-8935; 34-58030; File No. S7-15-08], RIN 3235-AK00, USSecurities and Exchange Commission, Washington, DC (27 June 2008—06 January2009), http://www.sec.gov/comments/s7-15-08/s71508.shtml.
US SEC. 2008c. Modernization of Oil and Gas Reporting. Conforming version(final), 17 CFR Parts 210, 211, 229, and 249, [Release Nos. 33-8995; 34-59192;FR-78; File No. S7-15-08], RIN 3235-AK00, US Securities and ExchangeCommission, Washington, DC (29 December 2008), http://www.sec.gov/rules/final/2008/33-8995.pdf.
US SEC. 2008d. SEC Settles Securities Fraud Case With El Paso Corporation,Its Subsidiaries, and Several Former Employees. Litigation Release No. 20642,Accounting and Auditing Enforcement Release No. 2844, US Securities andExchange Commission, Washington, DC (11 July 2008), http://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/2008/lr20642.htm. (accessed 22 June 2010).
US SEC. 2009b. Putting investors first: 2009 Performance and AccountabilityReport, http://sec.gov/about/secpar/secpar2009.pdf (downloaded 22 June 2010).
US SEC. 2010. The Investor's Advocate: How the SEC Protects Investors,Maintains Integrity, and Facilitates Capital Formation, http://sec.gov/about/whatwedo.shtml(accessed 1 March 2010).
Wascak, R. 2004. Oil and Gas Valuation Paper. Memorandum, Federal AccountingStandards Advisory Board (FASAB), Washington, DC (23 September 2004). http://www.fasab.gov/pdffiles/final_oil_gas_paper.pdf.(downloaded 22 June 2010).
White, T.T. 1964. Handling of Disclosure as to Reserves for the S.B.C. PaperSPE 971 presented at the SPE Annual Fall Meeting, Houston, 11-14 October. doi: 10.2118/971-MS.
Wyatt v. El Paso Corporation, et al. 2006. Stipulation and Agreement ofSettlement, 02-cv-2717 (S.D. Tx 26 October 2006), http://securities.stanford.edu/1025/EP02-01/20061026_r01s_022717.pdf.(downloaded 07 February 2010).