Misconceptions Regarding the Chemical Role of Completion/Packer Fluids in Annular Environmentally Assisted Cracking of Martensitic Stainless Steel Tubing
- Jeffrey S. McKennis (Tetra Technologies) | Nam Sook-Bae (Tetra Technologies) | Enrico J. Termine (Tetra Technologies) | Ken Shimamoto (JFE Steel Corporation) | Mitsuo Kimura (JFE Steel Corporation)
- Document ID
- Society of Petroleum Engineers
- SPE Journal
- Publication Date
- December 2010
- Document Type
- Journal Paper
- 1,098 - 1,103
- 2010. Society of Petroleum Engineers
- 4.2.3 Materials and Corrosion, 2.7.1 Completion Fluids
- bicarbonate, stress corrosion cracking, production tubing, packer fluid, brine
- 1 in the last 30 days
- 340 since 2007
- Show more detail
- View rights & permissions
|SPE Member Price:||USD 10.00|
|SPE Non-Member Price:||USD 30.00|
The increased use of corrosion resistant alloys (CRAs) in deep high-pressure/high-temperature (HP/HT) wells has led to production-tubing cracking failures throughout the industry. Many of these failures have occurred from the outside (annulus side) and have been attributed to environmentally assisted cracking (EAC) and, hence, are best described as annular EAC (AEAC). Examination of these failures points to a serious incompatibility of the production tubing metallurgy with the packer fluid under stress.
In 2003, combining expertise in fluid chemistry and metallurgy, the authors formed a research alliance to address the AEAC problem by examining the compatibility of a wide spectrum of completion fluids with various martensitic stainless steel (MSS) metallurgies. This unique research collaboration, involving extensive stress-cracking testing performed with different metallurgies and different fluids under simulated well conditions, has resulted in an extensive database (more than 4,000 test entries for 27 fluids and six MSS metallurgies) and a new body of knowledge regarding the causes behind AEAC failures.
Conventional wisdom holds that chloride ion and oxygen play major causative roles. The authors' findings, however, identify other contaminants in completion/packer fluids that play the dominant role in the chemical mechanism of the crack failures. Such contaminants include sulfur-containing species, oxidants other than oxygen, and select basic ionic species. This paper addresses the effect of the new information and identifies serious misconceptions regarding the role of completion /packer fluids in the tubular failures.
The authors' comprehensive study has advanced the industry's knowledge of the causes of AEAC by detailing the previously unrecognized importance of various contaminants present in the fluids. As a consequence, the need for quality assurance and best-practice fluid management throughout the life cycle of the fluids is now recognized. Misconceptions with respect to the chemical mechanisms and causative factors of AEAC failures are discussed. Such information should expand the industry's AEAC knowledge base and minimize the risk of tubular failure.
|File Size||108 KB||Number of Pages||6|
Asher, S., Singh, P.M., Colwell, J.A., and Leis, B.N. 2006. Stress CorrosionCracking of Pipeline Steel in Near-Neutral pH Environment. Paper 06175presented at the NACE International Corrosion 2006 61st Annual Conference andExposition, San Diego, California, 12-16 March.
Asher, S.L. and Singh, P.M. 2007. Investigating the Impact of Environment onTransgranular Stress Corrosion Cracking of Pipeline Steels. Paper 07130presented at the NACE International Corrosion 2007 Annual Conference andExposition, Nashville, Tennessee, 11-15 March.
Burke, P.A. et al. 1988. CO2 Corrosion Behavior of Carbon and Alloy Steel inHigh Concentration Brine Solution. Paper 212 presented at the NACEInternational Corrosion '88 43rd Annual Conference and Exposition, St. Louis,Missouri, 21-25 March.
Chiang, K.-T.K., Cragnolino, G.A., and Dunn, D.S. 2005. Effect of SimulatedGroundwater Chemistry on Stress Corrosion Cracking of Alloy 22. Paper 05463presented at the NACE International Corrosion 2005 60th Annual Conference andExposition, Houston, 3-7 April.
Chiang, K.-T.K., Dunn, D.S., and Cragnolino, G.A. 2006. The Combined Effectof Bicarbonate and Chloride Ions on the Stress Corrosion CrackingSusceptibility of Alloy 22. Paper 06506 presented at the NACE InternationalCorrosion 2006 61st Annual Conference and Exposition, San Diego, California,12-16 March.
Horton, R.L. and Arvie, M.A. 2007. Preventing Environmentally InducedCorrosion Cracking by Removal of Thiocyanates From Completion Fluids. PaperSPE 110111 presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition,Anaheim, California, 11-14 November. SPE-110111-MS. doi: 10.2118/110111-MS.
Javora, P.H., Ke, M., and Schultz, K. 2008. Effect of Chloride Concentration onthe Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC) of CRA Tubulars and Methods to Enhance SCCResistance in High-Temperature Environments. Paper SPE 116759 presented atthe SPE Technical Conference and Exhibition, Denver, 21-24 September.SPE-116759-MS. doi: 10.2118/116759-MS.
Kane, R.D., Trillo, E.A., McKennis, J.S., and Shimamoto, K. 2005. EvaluationProtocol and Monitoring of Corrosion and SCC of Stainless Steels in Clear BrineFluids. Paper 480 presented at Eurocorr 2005, Lisbon, Portugal, 4-8September.
Ke, M. and Qu, Q. 2006. ThermalDecomposition of Thiocyanate Corrosion Inhibitors: A Potential Problem forSuccessful Well Completions. Paper SPE 98302 presented at the InternationalSymposium and Exhibition on Formation Damage Control, Lafayette, Louisiana,USA, 15-17 February. doi: 10.2118/98302-MS.
Kermani, M.B. and Morshed, A. 2003. Carbon Dioxide Corrosion in Oil and GasProduction--A Compendium. Corrosion 59 (8): 659-683.
Kimura, M. 2006. Martensitic Stainless Steel Tubulars. 2nd AnnualChemiMetallurgy Technical Symposium, The Woodlands, Texas, November.
Kimura, M. 2007. CO2 Corrosion and SCC Mechanism for New MartensiticStainless Steel OCTG. 3rd Annual ChemiMetallurgy Technical Symposium, TheWoodlands, Texas, November.
Lo Piccolo, E., Scoppio, L., Nice, P.I. and Nødland, S. 2005. Corrosion and Environmental CrackingEvaluation of High Density Brines for Use in HPHT Fields. Paper SPE 97593presented at the SPE High Pressure/High Temperature Sour Well Design AppliedTechnology Workshop, The Woodlands, Texas, 17-19 May. SPE-97593-MS. doi:10.2118/97593-MS.
Mack, R., Williams, C., Lester, S., and Casassa, J. 2002. Stress CorrosionCracking of a Cold Worked 22Cr Duplex Stainless Steel ProductionTubing--Results of the Failure Analysis at Deep Alex and Associated LaboratoryExperiments in High Density Clear Brine CaCl2 Packer Fluid. Paper 02067presented at the NACE International Corrosion 2002 57th Annual Conference andExposition, Denver, 7-11 April.
McKennis, J.S. 2005. Clear Brine Fluid Corrosion Issues-SelectingMartensitic Stainless Steel Tubulars and Clear Brine Fluids for HPHT WellCompletions. Presented at the Fall 2005 ChemiMetallurgy Technical Symposium,The Woodlands, USA, November.
McKennis, J.S. 2006. ChemiMetallurgy Research Alliance New Findings.Presented at the 2nd Annual ChemiMetallurgy Technical Symposium, The Woodlands,Texas, USA, November.
McKennis, J.S. 2007. The Advantage of Zinc Completion Fluids. Presented atthe 3rd Annual ChemiMetallurgy Technical Symposium, The Woodlands, Texas, USA,November.
McKennis, J.S., Bae, N., Kimura, M, Shimamoto, K., and Sato, H. 2008a. A NewChemical Mechanistic Postulate Regarding Annular Environmentally AssistedCracking (AEAC)--Importance of Cations and Key Contaminants in Packer Fluids inCracking of Martensitic Steel. Paper 08483 presented at the NACE InternationalCorrosion 2008 Annual Conference and Exposition, New Orleans, 16-19 March.
McKennis, J.S., Termine E.J., Bae, N.S., Kimura, M, Shimamoto, K., and Sato,H. 2008b. The Role of PackerFluids in the Annular Environmentally Assisted Cracking of CRA ProductionTubing. Paper SPE 114131 presented at the SPE International OilfieldCorrosion Conference, Aberdeen, 27 May. SPE-114131-MS. doi:10.2118/114131-MS.
Mowat, D.E., Edgerton, M.C., and Wade, E.H.R. 2001. Erskine Field HPHT Workover andTubing Corrosion Failure Investigation. Paper SPE 67779 presented at theSPE/IADC Drilling Conference, Amsterdam, 27 February-1 March. SPE-67779-MS.doi: 10.2118/67779-MS.
NACE Standard TM0177-2005, Laboratory Testing of Metals for Resistance toSulfide Stress Cracking and Stress Corrosion Cracking in H2S Environments.2005. Houston: NACE International.
Rebak, R.B. 2006. Industrial Experience on the Caustic Cracking of StainlessSteels and Nickel Alloys--A Review. Paper 06501 presented at the NACEInternational Corrosion 2006 61st Annual Conference and Exposition, San Diego,California, 12-16 March.
Rebak, R.B. 2007. Environmental Cracking of Corrosion Resistant Alloys inthe Chemical Process Industry--A Review. Paper 07480 presented at the NACEInternational Corrosion 2007 Annual Conference and Exposition, Nashville,Tennessee, 11-15 March.
Rhodes, P.R. 2001. Environmental Assisted Cracking of Corrosion-ResistantAlloys in Oil and Gas Production Environment: A Review. Corrosion 57 (11): 923-966.
Robinson, E. 2004. Thiocyanate corrosion inhibitors suspected in chloridestress corrosion cracking. Offshore 64 (10): 64-66.
Scoppio, L., Nice, P.I., Nødland, S., and Piccolo, E.L. 2004. Corrosion andEnvironmental Cracking Testing of a High Density Brine for HPHT FieldApplication. NACE Paper 04113 presented at Corrosion 2004, New Orleans, 28March-1 April.
Stevens, R., Ke, M., Javora, P.H., and Qu, Q. 2004. Oilfield Environment-Induced StressCorrosion Cracking of CRAs in Completion Brines. Paper SPE 90188 presentedat the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Houston, 26-29September. SPE-90188-MS. doi: 10.2118/90188-MS.
Stumm, W. and Morgan, J.J. 1996. Aquatic Chemistry: Chemical Equilibriaand Rates in Natural Water, third edition. New York: Environmental Scienceand Technology, Wiley-Interscience.
Sutano, H. and Semerad, V.A.W. 1990. Annulus Corrosion in High-TemperatureGas Wells. SPE Prod & Eng 5 (3): 295-298.SPE-17678-PA. doi: 10.2118/17678-PA.
Sutcliffe, J.M., Fessler, R.R., Boyd, W.K. and Parkins, R.N. 1972. StressCorrosion Cracking of Carbon Steel in Carbonate Solutions. Corrosion 28 (8):126.
Termine, E. and Massoth, T. 2007. Understanding the chemistry of clear brinefluids is vital for best performance. World Oil (June 2007).
Trillo, E.A., Kane, R.D., McKennis, J., and Shimamoto, K. 2006. TestProtocol Development and Electrochemical Monitoring of Stainless Steels inPacker Fluid Environments. Paper 06136 presented at the NACE InternationalCorrosion 2006 61st Annual Conference and Exposition, San Diego, California,12-16 March.
Ueda, M. 2006. Development of Corrosion Resistance Alloys for the Oil andGas Industry--Based on Spontaneous Passivity Mechanism (2006 F.N. Speller AwardLecture). Corrosion 62 (10): 856-867.
Ueda, M., Nakamura, K., Hudson, N., Ibrahim, M.Z., Selamat, K., and Chen, P.2003. Corrosion Behavior of Super 13Cr Martensitic Stainless Steels inCompletion Fluids. Paper 03097 presented at the NACE International Corrosion2003 58th Annual Conference and Exposition, San Diego, California, March.