Litigation Against Unconventional Gas Producers: Lessons from the US Experience
- Richard M Lightfoot (Casconsult Pty Ltd)
- Document ID
- Society of Petroleum Engineers
- SPE Asia Pacific Unconventional Resources Conference and Exhibition, 9-11 November, Brisbane, Australia
- Publication Date
- Document Type
- Conference Paper
- 2015. Society of Petroleum Engineers
- 7 Management and Information, 5 Reservoir Desciption & Dynamics, 7.2.1 Risk, Uncertainty and Risk Assessment, 4.1 Processing Systems and Design, 4.1.2 Separation and Treating, 5.8.1 Tight Gas, 7.2 Risk Management and Decision-Making, 5.8 Unconventional and Complex Reservoirs, 4 Facilities Design, Construction and Operation, 5.8.3 Coal Seam Gas, 6.5.3 Waste Management
- Corporate Responsibility, Unconventional Gas Industry, Risk, Groundwater Contamination, Litigation
- 1 in the last 30 days
- 136 since 2007
- Show more detail
- View rights & permissions
|SPE Member Price:||USD 5.00|
|SPE Non-Member Price:||USD 28.00|
"Litigation against unconventional gas producers; lessons from the US experience."
Richard M Lightfoot, Casconsult Pty Ltd
In North America, exploration and production of oil and gas from unconventional sources principally shale, but also tight sandstones and coal seams – is more developed than elsewhere in the world. The presence of large shale, tight gas, and coal seam gas reserves has led to exploration throughout the world.
In Australia, the unconventional gas industry is most developed in Queensland, is seeking to expand in New South Wales and South Australia, and is prospective in Western Australia the Northern Territory, and, to a much lesser extent Victoria.
In the light of the US experience, which has included claims of mechanical failures and inappropriate waste treatment and disposal, leading to groundwater contamination, induced seismicity and hazardous fugitive emissions, government and scientific agencies have produced thousands of studies of the perceived benefits and risks associated with the gas.
In each jurisdiction where unconventional gas extractions has been proposed, governments have been developing legislative regimes for resource allocation and for the managing of risks, through statutes, regulations, standard, and codes of practice.
In the USA, landowners and other citizens who believe that unconventional gas extraction has caused damage to land, water, human and animal health, have resorted to ligation seeking to recover damages, principally by bringing tortuous claims in negligence, nuisance and trespass. In some jurisdiction, actions have also been based on strict liability and legislated rebuttable presumptions of liability.
The paper summarises some cases brought in the USA, to identify the basis of the claims and to analyse their outcomes. In particular, claims brought in tort, and the potential for such claims brought in Australia must be considered.
All sections of the Unconventional Gas Industry need to become aware of their continuing responsibilities. Corporations require an intimate knowledge of the law, its interpretation and the need to minimise exposure to financial, environmental and health risks.
|File Size||1 MB||Number of Pages||29|
Australia's federal Constitution is modelled on that of the USA, and has embedded separation of powers, with three Chapters providing separate heads of power for the Legislature, executive and Judiciary, and with strong Constitutional separation of powers in particular as between the legislature and the judiciary.
Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) (EPBC Act), Section 528 of the EPBC defines "coal seam gas development " as "any activity involving coal seam gas extraction that has, or is likely to have, a significant impact on water resources (including any impacts of associated salt production and/or salinity): (a) in its own right; or (b) when considered with other developments, whether past, present or reasonably foreseeable developments.
Gallasch, Rosita "Five-year fracking ban hailed" The Examiner (26/02/2015), HYPERLINK "http://www.examiner.com.au/story/2911238/five-year-fracking-ban-hailed/" http://www.examiner.com.au/story/2911238/five-year-fracking-ban-hailed/, accessed 30/08/2015
Hepburn, Samantha. Does Unconvential Gas Require Unconventional Ownership? Journal of Environmental and Public Health Law Vol 8 Issue 1. Winter 2013 http://pjephl.law.pitt.edu Pp 23 -46.
Lore v. Lone Pine Corp. No. L-33606-85 1986 WL. 635707 (N.J. Sup. Ct. Nov. 18, 1986). In order to streamline the proceedings in this toxic tort case, the court entered a case management order required the Plaintiffs to present certain basic facts regarding their claims of contamination from a landfill. First, the court required the Plaintiffs to provide the following documentation with respect to each personal injury claim: (i) facts of each individual Plaintiff's exposure to alleged toxic substances at or from the site, and (ii) reports from treating physicians and or other experts, supporting each individual Plaintiff's claim of injury and causation. The court then required the Plaintiffs to give the following with respect to the property damage claims: (i) location of the property; and (ii) reports from real estate or other experts supporting property damage claims, including the timing and degree of the damage as well as causation of the same.
Navigant.com/oilandgasenergy April 2015
Nikiforuk, Andrew. See the interview with Professor Ingraffea in ‘Shale Gas: Myth and Realities’, The Tyee, Vancouver, Canada, http://thetyee.ca/News/2013/01/07/Shale-Gas-realities/, accessed 22/5/2014.
Ridlington, Elizabeth & John Rumper, Env't AM. Research & Policy CTR: Fracking by the Numbers 4 (2013). available at http://www.environmentamerica.org/sites/environment/files/reports/EA_frackingnumbers_scrn.pdf
SPE, 2010. A small U.S. oil firm performed the first commercial frack job in 1947 in Kansas on a conventional gas well using 1,000 gallons of napalm as well as sand from the Arkansas River. Early hydraulic fracturing pumped small volumes (1,000 to 10,000 gallons) of toxic fluid into vertical wells (2,400 feet) using about 600 horsepower of pressure. HYPERLINK "http://www.spe.org/jpt/print/archives/2010/12/10Hydraulic.pdf" \t "_blank".
US Bureau of Land Management, published statistics. http://blm.gov/published.lan.statistics/p/s11/pds2011pdf
Arnold & Porter LLC, Hydraulic Fracturing, 2014. www.arnoldporter.com/resources/documents/hydraulic_fracturing_caseschart.pdf
Australian Mining Review, "Katherine Town Council Bans Fracking of Unconventional Gas" Australian Mining Review (27/02/2015), HYPERLINK "http://www.miningreview.com.au/news/katherine-town-council-bans-fracking-unconventional-gas/" http://www.miningreview.com.au/news/katherine-town-council-bans-fracking-unconventional-gas/ accessed 30/08/2015
Brady, Anthony. "Moyne in state-wide council anti-fracking push" The Standard (26/03/2014) HYPERLINK "http://www.standard.net.au/story/2175264/moyne-in-statewide-council-anti-fracking-push/" http://www.standard.net.au/story/2175264/moyne-in-statewide-council-anti-fracking-push/, accessed 30/08/2015
Doutré, Cimara. " Glenelg Shire has declared itself a coal seam gas free zone" The Weekly Times, (27/08/2013), HYPERLINK "http://www.weeklytimesnow.com.au/news/national/glenelg-shire-has-declared-itself-a-coal-seam-gas-free-zone/story-fnkfnspy-1227038849982" http://www.weeklytimesnow.com.au/news/national/glenelg-shire-has-declared-itself-a-coal-seam-gas-free-zone/story-fnkfnspy-1227038849982, accessed 30/08/2015
Gray, Darren. "Lift ban on gas exploration, urges council" Farmonline.com.au (9/08/2015) HYPERLINK "http://www.farmonline.com.au/news/metro/national/general/lift-ban-on-gas-exploration-urges-council/2739947.aspx" http://www.farmonline.com.au/news/metro/national/general/lift-ban-on-gas-exploration-urges-council/2739947.aspx, accessed 30/08/2015
Hepburn, Samantha "Who owns coal seam gas in New South Wales (and who can stop it being mined)?" The Conversation (11 May 2012), HYPERLINK "http://theconversation.com/who-owns-coal-seam-gas-in-new-south-wales-and-who-can-stop-it-being-mined-6969" http://theconversation.com/who-owns-coal-seam-gas-in-new-south-wales-and-who-can-stop-it-being-mined-6969, accessed 23/08/2015
Kennedy, Mayor Lyall "Ashfield council says no to coal seam gas mining," (10 April 2012), HYPERLINK "http://www.ashfield.nsw.gov.au/files//your_council/newsroom/mayoral_columns_2012/april/10_3_12_final_coal_seam_gas.pdf" http://www.ashfield.nsw.gov.au/files//your_council/newsroom/mayoral_columns_2012/april/10_3_12_final_coal_seam_gas.pdf accessed 23/08/2015
"Los Angeles becomes largest US city to prohibit fracking" rt.com, (1/03/2014), http://www.rt.com/usa/los-angeles-fracking-ban-290/
News.com.au "Council coal seam gas ban to face legal challenge" (9/05/2023) HYPERLINK "http://www.news.com.au/breaking-news/council-coal-seam-gas-ban-to-face-legal-challenge/story-e6frfku0-1226351207575" http://www.news.com.au/breaking-news/council-coal-seam-gas-ban-to-face-legal-challenge/story-e6frfku0-1226351207575, accessed 22/08/2015
Nicholls, Sean "Ban on fracking to protect more homes," Sydney Morning Herald, (3/10/2013), HYPERLINK "http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/ban-on-fracking-to-protect-more-homes-20131002-2usuf.html" \l "ixzz3kGSHiE8c" http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/ban-on-fracking-to-protect-more-homes-20131002-2usuf.html#ixzz3kGSHiE8c
The Orange City Council's resolution states: That Orange City Council create a policy banning any and all Coal Seam Gas in the Orange Council area, in affect creating Orange as a Coal Seam Gas Free Zone. That Orange City Council as a member of Centroc, request that our Motion be considered as a Centroc wide policy for ALL Member Councils in Centroc. That Council seek support for this policy through the Association of Mining Related Councils. That Council supports NSW Farmers in their opposition to coal seam gas mining
Orange City Council, Minutes of the Ordinary Meeting of the Orange City Council held at the Civic Centre on 15 April 2014, HYPERLINK "http://www.orange.nsw.gov.au/client_images/1558206.pdf" http://www.orange.nsw.gov.au/client_images/1558206.pdf, accessed 22/08/2015.
Singleton Argus "No more gas" HYPERLINK "http://www.singletonargus.com.au/story/1317547/council-reaffirms-gas-opposition" http://www.singletonargus.com.au/story/1317547/council-reaffirms-gas-opposition (22/02/2013). Accessed 30/08/2015 Council, http://www.singletonargus.com.au/story/1317547/council-reaffirms-gas-opposition/
Somerset Regional Council, Minutes of Ordinary Council Meeting held on 11 January 2012, http://www.somerset.qld.gov.au/documents/611941/5765093/2012%2001%2011%20SRC%20Ordinary%20Minutes.pdf
Stop CSG Sydney, "About," http://stopcsgsydney.org.au/about/
Stop CSG Sydney, "Marrickville Council to request NSW Govt. to revoke Dart licence on St Peters" (25 May 2013), HYPERLINK "http://stopcsgsydney.org.au/marrickville-council-to-request-nsw-govt-to-revoke-dart-licence-on-st-peters/" http://stopcsgsydney.org.au/marrickville-council-to-request-nsw-govt-to-revoke-dart-licence-on-st-peters/ accessed 23/08/2015
Stop CSG Sydney, Marrickville Council signs on to the campaign to cancel the coal seam gas license covering Sydney Basin, (15 October 2014), HYPERLINK "http://stopcsgsydney.org.au/marrickville-council-signs-on-to-the-campaign-to-cancel-the-coal-seam-gas-license-covering-sydney-basin/" http://stopcsgsydney.org.au/marrickville-council-signs-on-to-the-campaign-to-cancel-the-coal-seam-gas-license-covering-sydney-basin/ accessed 23/08/2015
Sydney Morning Herald, "Bligh mystified by council's coal seam gas ban" (12 January 2012), HYPERLINK "http://www.smh.com.au/environment/bligh-mystified–by-councils-coal-seam-gas-ban-20120112-1px0p.html" \l "ixzz3jcK0gLJD" http://www.smh.com.au/environment/bligh-mystified–by-councils-coal-seam-gas-ban-20120112-1px0p.html#ixzz3jcK0gLJD accessed 23/08/2015
The full resolution adopted by the Wagga Wagga Council states: "That Council Place a moratorium on coal seam gas (CSG) exploration on all lands under the care and/or control of Wagga Wagga City Council in the Wagga Wagga Local Government Area (LGA) and call for a full assessment by the State Government of the impacts of the activity of CSG on the sustainability of agricultural production and aquifers in the LGA Place a moratorium on seismic testing to be conducted on any roads or lands under the care and/or control of Wagga Wagga City Council for the purposes of CSG exploration not accept any donations, grants or gifts from any CSG companies or associated organisations or their representatives write a letter of in-principle support to the Lock The Gate organisation and include in this letter the position of Council outlined in this resolution nominate the Mayor to officially present a copy of this resolution to our current State and Federal local members and forward this resolution to the relevant State and Federal Ministers place notification of this resolution on Council's website present this resolution to our partner Councils at Riverina Eastern Regional Organisation of Councils (REROC) for their consideration.
Wagga City Council, Minutes of the Ordinary Meeting of Council held on Monday 24 March 2014; HYPERLINK "http://www.wagga.nsw.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0003/28767/OC_24032014_MIN.pdf" http://www.wagga.nsw.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0003/28767/OC_24032014_MIN.pdf, accessed 22/08/2015.