The Hydrothermal Chemistry of Formate Brines and Its Impact on Corrosion in HPHT Wells
- Siv Killie Howard (Cabot Specialty Fluids) | John Downs (Cabot Specialty Fluids)
- Document ID
- Society of Petroleum Engineers
- SPE International Oilfield Corrosion Conference, 27 May, Aberdeen, UK
- Publication Date
- Document Type
- Conference Paper
- 2008. Society of Petroleum Engineers
- 5.4.10 Microbial Methods, 2.2.2 Perforating, 4.3.1 Hydrates, 4.1.3 Dehydration, 6.5.4 Naturally Occurring Radioactive Materials, 2 Well Completion, 4.2.3 Materials and Corrosion, 4.1.2 Separation and Treating, 3 Production and Well Operations, 5.6.4 Drillstem/Well Testing, 2.7.1 Completion Fluids
- 1 in the last 30 days
- 480 since 2007
- Show more detail
- View rights & permissions
|SPE Member Price:||USD 9.50|
|SPE Non-Member Price:||USD 28.00|
Formate brines have been successfully used in hundreds of HPHT drilling and completion operations over the past 12 years and have exhibited remarkable thermal stability. This has been confirmed by analyses of brines recovered from extreme HPHT wells after lengthy exposure (months/years). Laboratory testing cited in the literature has, however, indicated that significant formate brine decomposition to bicarbonate and hydrogen gas should occur at even relatively low temperatures if the brine is in contact with catalytic surfaces. The potential damage that such decomposition and the evolution of decomposition products could cause to metallic materials has caused concern in the industry.
The inconsistency between laboratory and field behavior has indicated that standard laboratory autoclaves are not suited for reproducing or simulating downhole conditions. Typical differences between these two environments are pressure, presence of gas cap, and amount and type of catalytic surfaces. In order to better simulate actual downhole conditions, experiments have been carried out in specialist equipment developed to examine hydrothermal chemistry. A non-catalytic gold test cell was used for the decomposition testing, immersed in a high pressure high temperature autoclave filled with water.
The flexibility of the gold cell has allowed experiments to be conducted and sampled at high pressure without the presence of an artificial gas cap. Initial tests have shown that any decomposition reactions taking place in formate brine under hydrothermal conditions will reach equilibrium with bicarbonate. This discovery has also given us useful information on how to formulate bicarbonate-rich formate brine compositions which remain stable even at very high temperatures. As bicarbonate is an important component in buffered formate brines, these formulations are not much different from the current brines already in field use.
Analyses of a range of formate brine samples that have been recovered from two HPHT wells have confirmed that formate reaches equilibrium with bicarbonate over time under hydrothermal conditions.
This paper reviews what has been learnt about formate decomposition under realistic hydrothermal conditions, and exposes new information on how the equilibrium reactions might impact on metal integrity and corrosion processes in HPHT wells.
The most important lesson learned from testing in the flexible gold cell is that traditional laboratory autoclaves operated with a gaseous head space are not suited for testing formate brines at high temperatures. In fact, test results generated in such autoclaves will be laboratory artifacts that do not simulate or reproduce what actually happens in HPHT wells.
Formate brines were originally designed and developed for use as high-performance HPHT drilling and completion fluids 1,2,3 and have been deployed in more than 150 HPHT wells since 19964. Over this time they have been exposed for lengthy periods (typically 30 - 60 days, but sometimes for more than a year) to well temperatures of up to 225°C / 437°F without any substantial change in composition or properties (i.e. no noticable build up of decomposition products, such as bicarbonate and hydrogen or changes in density, pH, etc).
Such resistance to thermal degradation or transformation under HPHT conditions is not intuitive, given that the technical literature contains several examples of laboratory experiments showing that formates in aqueous solutions can decompose appreciably at high temperatures.
It seems that there is no obvious correlation between field experience and results of laboratory tests using HPHT autoclaves. In other words, it appears that no researchers have yet managed to simulate or reproduce the conditions experienced by formate brines in HPHT wells. This is perhaps not surprising given that HPHT wells are effectively very long tubular hydrothermal reactors lined with a variety of catalytic surfaces.
|File Size||164 KB||Number of Pages||12|